Think you know your stuff about The Constitution?  Click to find out!
Read what the Supreme Court thinks about Affirmative Action in Batson v. Kentucky

Site Links

• The Foundations
     of Americanism

• Historic Document
     Library

     • The Declaration of
        Independence

     • The U.S. Constitution
     • The Bill of Rights
     • The Amendments
• Supreme Court Cases
• Today In History
Article Archives --
     • Editorials
     • Opinion
     • In-Depth
     • Headlines
     • Court Challenges

• About Us

Site Search

Go
     Search Tips

Read or Post Mail
by Topic


Home Page
Utah and the Tenth
Know Your Stuff?

Fact lists about ...
U.S. Presidents
States & Territories
States Ranked
U.S. Chief Justices
U.S. Wars & Conflicts
Fed'l Debt & Spending
116th Congress

Flash Stats on ...
Congress
The Supreme Court
Tax Freedom Day

Take our
Americana Quiz
Sunday, March 3, 2024 - National Anthem Day
Inside the Latest Biden Showdown With Second Amendment Devotees - James Bovard
An open threat to repeat the sins of law enforcement's recent past.

NFL Has Become a Woke, Discriminatory, Anti-American Institution - Hans von Spakovsky
Professional football has intentionally fumbled e pluribus unum.


Headlines
Today in History:  New Anthem: Star Spangled Banner (1931) ... Florida Admitted to Union (1845) ... Birth of Alexander Graham Bell (1847) ... Interior Department Established (1849) ... Birth of General Matthew B. Ridgeway (1895) ... Treaty Takes Russia Out of WWI (1918)

     ... More Headlines

Constitutional Challenges in Court

Chief Justice Edward D. WhiteHistoric Decisions On This Date:  Schenck v. United States (1919, Free Speech)

A Tough Speech Case at the Supreme Court - Douglas Andrews
This case stinks. That's it in a nutshell for conservatives.

Alabama Supreme Court's Embryo Ruling Embodies America's Legal Heritage - Josh Hammer
The Left is decrying a ruling which fits not only state law, but science.

     ... More Constitutional Challenges

Opinion
Taxation Without Reason - John Stossel
We adjust our lives to satisfy the whims of politicians and their taxes.

How Corrupt Are Democrats? This Corrupt... - David Strom
If only it were a parody...

Middle America Is Dying Hard - Salena Zito
Washington, media and online elites just don't get Middle America.

While Biden Pushes Ukraine To Fight, He Demands Israel Surrender - David Harsanyi
There is no one, no issue, the president won't sell out for votes.

Biden's Nonsensical Immigration Bill - Armstrong Williams
A masterpiece of duplicity and illegality is President Joe Biden.

Blue Laws For Red Citizens - Victor Davis Hanson
There are eerie commonalities in all five court cases aimed at Mr. Trump.

Constitution? What Constitution? - David Strom
We are told that Trump will destroy the Republic, while Biden is doing it.

Good News: Fertilized Embryos Are Human Lives, Says Alabama - Emmy Griffin
Logic prevails. The pro-death Left is not happy.

Migrant Crime Is Turning Cities Into War Zones - Betsy McCaughey
Lawbreakers, brutes and gang leaders: Stay in the countries you ruined!

     ... More Op-Ed


Utah and the Tenth —  

The trouble with the Ninth and Tenth Amendments to the Constitution — the last two items in the Bill of Rights — has not been lack of clarity. The Tenth, at least, is extremely clear: “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.”

 

The problem has been one of enforcement. How do the States prevent the federal government from overreach? Especially when the federal government acts as if no objection to a federal law could be brooked? Especially when the Supreme Court is, ahem, wrong, or hasn’t yet been approached with a challenge.

 

Utah has rediscovered an old technique. And revived it. Governor Spencer Cox signed into law the “Utah Constitutional Sovereignty Act”: “The Legislature may, by concurrent resolution, prohibit a government officer from enforcing or assisting in the enforcement of a federal directive within the state if the Legislature determines the federal directive violates the principles of state sovereignty.”

 

Ultra clear. And by old precedent — the non-enforcement of The Fugitive Slave Act by some northern states — it provides teeth to the Tenth. If the federal government were to enact (just stretch your mind a bit!) something obviously unconstitutional, like, say, a gun confiscation, the state legislature would simply vote to prohibit any state employee, or subsidiary of the state (county, municipality) from working with federal agents. Federal government agencies don’t have enough manpower to enforce all the rules. The feds rely on the states.

 

CNN quotes a Democrat representative running against Governor Cox suggesting that the use of this technique would be overruled by the Supreme Court using “the Supremacy Clause.”

 

No. The Supremacy Clause only applies to the federal government regarding specified (“enumerated”) powers. 

 

Regarding matters not explicitly stated in the Constitution, it is the States that are supreme.

 

Or the People.


Paul Jacob, thisiscommonsense.com
Post Comment on States Rights ... or Read Comments
Visitor Posts (latest first)
PKT - Liberate Government Workers ...  TM - Landrieu's Myth ...  TM - Hillary Clinton Supporters ...  PKT - Nationalism and Populism ...  TM - The Mizzou Meltdown ...  TM - The Second Indictment ...  PKT - America: Love It Or Leave ...  E.F - Munn v. Illinois ...  PKT - Is Thinking Now Obsolete? ...  PKT - Cops or Soldiers? ...  TM - The Great American Con ...  TM - The Imperial Presidency ...  R G McCollum - Document located in Gen ...  PKT - The Progressive Degradation ...  PKT - It's More Than Just ...  TM - Rescuing Citizenship ... 

James Monroe"How prone all human institutions have been to decay; how subject the best-formed and most wisely organized governments have been to lose their check and totally dissolve; how difficult it has been for mankind, in all ages and countries, to preserve their dearest rights and best privileges, impelled as it were by an irresistible fate of despotism." - James Monroe, speech in the Virginia Ratifying Convention  (1788)



Copyright © 1999-2024 Common Sense Americanism - All rights reserved
Localizations by DB-IP
Privacy Policy   Submitting Articles   Site Guide & Info
Home Page